Filet Mignon with Creamy English Stilton Sauce

With my fiance in Florida, relaxing on the beach during school vacation, I am home alone and forced to cook for myself. Cooking for one is a difficult thing task for someone like me who typically makes enough food to feed and entire baseball team when it’s just the two of us eating. I was determined to stay on budget and finish the meal with no leftovers… even if it meant cleaning my second plate as a late night snack.

The East Broadway Stop & Shop has been closed all week for renovations (hopefully meaningful ones), so I ventured into the South End to a small market that I had heard about. It’s called Foodie’s Urban Market, and it definitely lived up to the hype. Fresh produce, a separate butcher section, and aisles of gourmet ingredients make this market my new quick stop location.

It certainly beats the old Stop and Shop where it takes 45 minutesto dig through a mountain of yellow onions before I find one without a mushy hole in it. I walked into this place with no ideas in mind, and wound up in the same place I started an hour later. With nothing accomplished, and nothing in my basket I had to make a split second decision before I got kicked out for loitering. I ended up leaving with an 8oz. Filet Mignon, 2 shallots, and a block of English Stilton. Stilton is an extremely strong smelling, cow’s milk blue cheese from England.

It’s distinctive blue veins are created by piercing the crust with stainless steel needles that allows air into the core of the wheel. A recent survey proves that eating English Stilton within one hour of sleep causes 75% of men and 85% of women to experience “odd and vivid” dreams. I don’t know what that means and I’m not sure that I want to, but there wasn’t enough cheese left to consume after dinner anyway.

I came home and started making a cheese sauce for my steak. I started by making a light roux (equal parts butter and flour whisked over moderate heat), which acts as a binder to thicken my sauce.

I poured in some heavy cream and cubes of the gorgeous blue cheese, which slowly dissolved into a thick, gurgling cream sauce. I finished it with a healthy pinch of freshly cracked black peppercorns and a sprinkle of chopped parsley. I love steak, and Filet is probably my least favorite cut of meat. I am a flavor junkie, and the marbling in a Filet Mignon just doesn’t cut it for me.

I usually go for a ribeye for its fat that weaves itself throughout the meat and then melts into the flesh when it hits the grill. Tonight was different because I was making an insanely rich sauce, packed with flavor, that it was okay to substitute flavor for tenderness. I seasoned the Filet liberally and seared it in a smoking hot pan before finishing it in the oven.

The outside of the meat formed a nice black pepper crust, leaving the center pink and juicy. During the last couple minutes of cooking, I threw a pad of butter on top of the Filet and let it melt into the flesh (I couldn’t resist… why do you think steakhouse steaks taste better than when you make them at home??). For some additional texture, I topped the steak with a heaping mound of fried shallots before spooning the pungent, creamy Stilton sauce all over the plate. I sat at the barstool in my kitchen and watched Sunday Night Baseball while devouring this, and sipping a 2006 Cameron Hughes Lot 74 Cabernet Sauvignon.

All of the Cabernet grapes in this wine come from the Oak Knoll District in Napa, which tends to be a cooler climate region than most Cabernet growing zones. The result is more of a Bordeaux meets California style… a clash between old and new world. It definitely wasn’t your typical fruit bomb, powerful California Cab. It was loaded with cassis and espresso flavors that balanced beautifully with the tannins. In my opinion, this is a wine that structurally could hold up for quite some time in a cellar. It was a great match for the Filet, because it was quite elegant and sexy. A grilled ribeye might have overpowered this wine. After the game I went to bed, and had a dream that I was having a heart attack. It was extremely vivid, but not quite so odd…. it must have been the Stilton.

































































